Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Jeremiah: Chapters 1 to 6

Here is the end of Isaiah.  Now for the next prophet - Jeremiah.



CHAPTER 1

Here it is – the Cassandra of ancient Judah: Jeremiah. 

There is quite a bit more biographical info about him than there was about Isaiah, and it starts off like a biography.  The first biographical parts might seem dry, but they are actually really important.  We’re told that he is the son of a priest named Hilkiah and became a prophet during the reign of Josiah.

OK, let’s unpack all of this.  Josiah’s reign?  That’s a big, important time.  He’s the Bible’s favorite king of the divided kingdom era.  He is promoted heavily in the historical books as the ideal king.  He was the big religious reformer.  During his reign, priests uncovered a seemingly lost book of wisdom from Moses (a book scholars universally regard to be Deuteronomy, as it says all the stuff that Josiah actually does in his period of reform). 

That “lost” book of Deuteronomy was presented to Josiah by a priest in verse 4 of Chapter 22 in Kings II.  That priest’s name?  Hilkiah.  That’s right – the same name as Jeremiah’s dad, who is also listed as a priest – and Jeremiah himself becomes a prophet of the Lord during the reign of Josiah.

Coincidence?  Well – part of it could be, actually.  There could always be a second priest named Hilkiah.  Stranger things have happened.  But it sure sounds interesting, doesn’t it?  Jeremiah will be the prophet of the Deuteronomy reforms.  The Biblical scholar Richard Elliot Friedman has even argued that Jeremiah might be the actual author of Deuteronomy (and all the historical books that come after it – Joshua, Judges, the Samuels, and the Kings). 

All that, from those opening verses of dry biographical info.

On, and we’re told something else pretty interesting shortly after.  We’re told that God decided to make Jeremiah a prophet “before I formed you in the womb.”  Huh.  Isaiah mentioned something like this, but it was a throwaway comment in the midst of that never ending book.  This is the fifth verse of the first chapter – front and center for all to see.  St. Paul will later make a similar claim about himself, but the third person claim here just sounds more impressive.  And again, I don’t think St. Paul’s claim is so front and center.  So Jeremiah is a prophet’s prophet.

What will be the purpose of Jeremiah’s prophecy?  Will it be to guide the Jews to the Promised Land like Moses?  Will it be to shepherd them when they need help?  Will it be to provide solace for those in needs?  Eh, not so much.  For Jeremiah, the point will be, “to uproot and to tear down, to destroy and to demolish, to build and to plant.”  OK, that last bit sounds positive, but the main theme is of a Destroyer Prophet.  Don’t see too many of those, now do you? 

That is fitting though, because no prophet will have a rockier road of dealing with the masses than Jeremiah.  He is not only a doom saying, but he just really needs to read “How to Win Friends and Influence People.”  He is just so damn abrasive.  So it makes sense that he’s described in such contentious language right from the word go.

Jeremiah initially wants nothing to do with this, by the way.  Like Moses and Gideon before him, when he finds out he’s been called, Jeremiah tries to wiggle out of it.  God tells Jeremiah to overcome his fears and never worry – God will be with him.   God acknowledges that people will oppose him (naturally – Jeremiah will pronounce doom repeatedly) but God will always be with him.

This does a nice job setting up what kind of prophet Jeremiah will be.

CHAPTER 2

OK, so the first chapter does a nice job setting him up, but the second chapter provides the first real taste of Jeremiah. 

He starts off by calling the Hebrew a bunch of whores.  That’s his opening statement.  Well, officially, he begins by comparing the relationship between God and the Hebrew as a relationship between a husband and wife, but he then makes clear that the Jews prostituted themselves to any God who came their way.  So, yeah, they’re a bunch of whores.  This isn’t just me extrapolating.  Jeremiah specifically says, “you sprawled and served as a prostitute.”  Whores.  He then calls them a lust-filled camel.  Well, points for originality, I guess. 

It’s an effective diatribe, but I fear that Jeremiah is getting lost in the process and not thinking of the result.  Ask yourselves this – what’s the purpose of his prophecy?  What is his ultimate goal?  I assume it’s to get people to return to God.  He wants them to quit backsliding and go back to old school Deuteronomy-like worship. (Let’s never mind that Deuteronomy isn’t old school, and his just been written – possibly by this guy). 

Look, if you want people to return to the Lord, is this really the best way of going about it?  If you want to win someone over to your religion, should you really start off by saying, “Hey you!  The sprawled out whore with the morals of a lusty camel!  Worship God the way I do!”  Doesn’t that sound massively counterproductive to anyone else? 

You lead with the insult, and you make people defensive.  They are upset with you, and just shut down any/all arguments you make.  Like I said, he needs to read “How to Win Friends and Influence People” but good. 

It also makes you wonder about Jeremiah.  Part of being good at dealing with people is being able to relate to them.  Can you empathize with them?  Jeremiah pretty much can’t.  He relates to scripture and the word of the Lord (never mind that he may have written it). What he thinks is right is all there is to it.  Yeah, that isn’t that good.  He talks of people, but can’t relate to individual persons.

CHAPTER 3

Jeremiah again begins with the husband-wife analogy.  If a man divorces his wife and she leaves him, and then becomes the wife of another – can she return to the first?   That’s his analogy against the Hebrew.  They had God and they walked out on them, so screw them.  But modern day law, of course, would let them get back together.  We’re more forgiving that Jeremiah is.

Boy, he isn’t forgiving anyone.  He calls them whores again: “Raise your eyes to the heights and look, where have men not lain with you?”  Man, Judah – you humped men all over the landscape!  Glancing through it again, he uses the words “prostitute” or “prostitution” five times, traitor at least twice, and adultery once.  I’m probably missing some references, too.  All this in 10 verses.  Man, he his nasty.

Jeremiah does shift gears midway through and says how they can get back to the Lord.  So all his mean spirited insults earlier were for naught, eh?  But you must admit your guilt and go back to the pure ways. In other words, you have to admit your guilt, beg forgiveness, and act like that book of Deuteronomy says. 

CHAPTER 4

This is more prophecies of doom.  The big one is a more specific one.  Instead of just generalized bemoaning of the Hebrew, Jeremiah drops a bomb on them – they’ll be invaded from the North. And it won’t be pretty, either: “Up comes the lion from its lair, the destroyer of nations has set out, has left its place, to turn your land  into a desolation, your cities into an uninhabited waste.”  He means Assyria, I think.  Or Babylon.  Babylon actually will take over, but I forget if there’s another failed Assyrian attack to come before Babylon takes over.

But he makes the northern power sound like the machine from Terminator.  Babylon is a cyborg from the future come to fulfill God’s punishment upon his lusty camel of a chosen people.

And they are coming as God’s punishment.  The people have just sinned and turned away from God. 

CHAPTER 5

We get more denouncing of the Hebrew.  It starts off with Jeremiah saying, “Roam the streets of Jerusalem, look about and observe.  Search through her squares, to find even one who act justly and seeks honesty and I will pardon her!”  So there isn’t a single good person in Jerusalem.  I could be wrong, but I think Jeremiah’s folk are from Shiloh.  (checks Chapter 1).  It just says from the land of Benjamin there.  I wonder if there is some sort of territorial grudges going on around here – like Chicago versus downstate.  Benjamin is the small tribe and Jerusalem the big capital. 

You also get the most Jermemiah-esque Jeremiad that Jeremiah ever Jeremiaded: “Pay attention to this, you foolish and senseless people.”  That perfectly captures his spirit.  To be fair, he follows it up with a great couplet – here’s the full thing: “Pay attention to this, you foolish and senseless people, who have eyes and do not see, who have ears and do not hear.”  That’s well done, but he is suck a dick in the first half, who will still be hearing him out in the second half?

You know what I just realized?  Jeremiah is the MGL of the Bible.  MGL is a well-respected sabemetrician who does a lot of great research and is often right – just as Jeremiah is one of the great prophets who speaks with the word of the Lord.  But in both cases, people rarely pay attention to the meat of his message because they so dislike his tone of voice.  Threads on MGL’s comments are often a series of attacks on him for being a jerk, and Jeremiah sure won’t have many friends in this Bible.

CHAPTER 6

More doom.  We’re still in his visions of invaders from the North.  In this entire section of prophecy, I kept writing “Bummer” in the margins.  Jeremiah notes, “Be warned, Jerusalem, or I will be estranged from you, and I will turn you into a wilderness, a land where no one dwells.”  Bummer.

Later: “Yes, husband and wife will be taken, elder with ancient.  Their houses will fall to others, their fields and their wives as well.”  Bummer.  Also: “Elder with ancient.”  That seems botched up, like he was going to contrast two different things but screwed up and said the same thing twice.  Hey, who knows – maybe this is something that got messed up in translation 2,500 years ago and we’ve been stuck with it ever since.

Here’s a line I liked: “Therefore they will fall among the fallen.”  It’s not too ambitious, but I just like how it sounds.

Jeremiah moves in a different direction later on.  Oh, he’s still damn negative on the Hebrew, but he finds a particular focus for his wrath: hypocrisy.  He notes how people violate all God’s commandments and then figure they can just give a sacrifice and it’s all cool.  But Jeremiah, echoing previous Bible chapters (Isaiah?  Some of the wisdom books?  I forget, to be honest), says: “Your burnt offerings find no favor with me, your sacrifices do not please me.” 

This is an advancement on Hebrew theology.  Go back and read Leviticus.  It was all about actions.  It didn’t stress belief or morality so much right there.  Commit a misdeed – do the sacrifice.  That had the advantage of making the priest’s job important.  They were in charge of sacrifices after all. 

But for people like Jeremiah, that isn’t enough.  He’s had enough of people who don’t really feel the Lord inside them.  Heck, this simple version of religion is one reason so many are also able to dabble with other gods, like Baal.  After all, you just have to do the ritual to make it good with God, so why get too caught up in it.  Prophets like Jeremiah who emphasize a deeper level of religion will help make this religion stick.  It’s a big reason why the Jews do a much better job observing their Lord’s duties in the post-kingdom years, because they’re being held to a higher standard. 

Jeremiah main page

Chapters 1 to 6
Chapters 7 to 13
Chapters 14 to 20
Chapters 21 to 28
Chapters 29 to 35
Chapters 36 to 45
Chapters 46 to 52

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Isaiah: Chapters 56 to 66

Here is the previous bit.  Now for the final bit.


CHAPTER 56

I like this chapter.  It goes directly against one of my least favorite Old Testament themes.  At times in the Old Testament (including portions of Isaiah), God is far too parochial.  He might be God of it all, but he only has his Chosen People that he cares about.  Anyone not descended from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob can go stick it.

This takes the opposite approach.  Anyone from foreign nations who is down with God is cool.  Well, Isaiah puts it a tad more eloquently than that: “Any foreigners who join themselves to the Lord to minister to him, to love the name of the Lord, to become his servants.  All who keep the Sabbath without profaning it, and hold fast to my covenant, them I will bring to my holy mountain and make them joyful in my house of prayer. Their burnt offerings and their sacrifice will be acceptable on my altar, for my house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples.”

A house of prayer for all peoples?  Now that is a Lord worth rallying behind.  And again – that’s very much a Christian-type of sentiment in a book filled with them.

CHAPTER 57

This starts off with Isaiah ranting against the wicked, but midway through he shifts gears.  The shift begins when he says, “But whoever takes refuge in me shall inherit the land.”  Boom – another Christ-like link.  “Inherit the ____” will be the main construction of the Sermon of the Mount. 

God has another line a little later that I just love: “I dwell in a high and holy place, but also with the contrite and lowly of spirit.”  That sounds like a good plan, God.  It’s those people feeling contrite and lowly most in need of your aid. 

God also gets off a nice line about the wicked: “But the wicked are like the tossing seas which cannot be still.  Its waters cast up mire and mud.  There is no peace for the wicked, says my God.”   Ever felt pissed and self-destructively angry?  You feel like a tossing sea when you get in that kind of mood.

CHAPTER 58

This one is all about justice and righteousness.  It’s not just what you do, but how you do it.  God begins by upbraiding those who fast for the wrong reasons.  They fast just like they’re supposed to but then are upset at God for not getting instant gratification.  Isaiah tells them, “Do not fast as you do today, to make your voice heard on high.”  Yo – the purpose of fasting isn’t for your own ego.  Even worse, some guys driver all their laborers really hard on the day of fasting.  Man, that ain’t kosher. 

Isaiah comments, “Is it not sharing your bread with the hungry, bringing the afflicted and the homeless into your house, clothing the naked when you see them, and not turning your back on your own flesh?”  This is what you’re supposed to do – you’re supposed to help out your fellow man; the lowlier, the more in need of helping.

That is just the prophet getting warmed up.  He gets to his big finish, which is one of the Bible’s best statements on justice: “If you remove the yoke from among you, the accusing finger, the malicious speech; if you lavish your food on the hungry and satisfy the afflicted; then your light shall rise in the darkness, and your gloom shall become like midday.  Then the Lord will guide you always and satisfy your third in parched places, will give strength to your bones and you shall be like a watered garden, like a flowing spring whose waters never fail.”  Yeah, nice way of putting it, Isaiah. 

CHAPTER 59

This is standard stuff.  The people have sinned and therefore they’re being justly punished.  It’s the same old same old. “The Good Book” by David Plotz has a great line about Isaiah.  He said it’s filled with a lot of the Bible’s junk DNA.  You get all these statements and curses and comments about God and man – it isn’t bad, but you hear it over and over and it gets repetitive.

There is one great line in this chapter.  Discussing how the people act now that God has hidden his face from them, Isaiah notes, “We stumble at midday as if at twilight.”  Yeah, that’s well put.

CHAPTER 60

This is a very upbeat chapter about Jerusalem and how awesome it will be.  Everyone will come and pay homage – not just the Jews, but all will, “gather and come to you.”  (With you meaning God, naturally).  There is a trace of foreshadowing the New Testament when we’re told, “All from Sheba shall come, bearing gold and frankincense.”  Those along with myrrh will be given to the baby Christ, of course. 

The main theme is that paradise will come.  All glory will happen.

It’s interesting, because I’ve been told – including by the opening notes to Isaiah in this very Bible – that Chapters 56-66 are from Third Isaiah, the period after exile ended.  Maybe, but so far I’m not seeing it.  I’m seeing a bunch of talk about Jerusalem once the exile ends, but it isn’t really clear that the end of exile is an accomplished fact or if it’s just wishful thinking.  Frankly, it sounds more like the former.  I’m probably missing something.  The Bible scholars know this material a lot better than I do, clearly.  But so far, everything I’m reading could’ve been written/spoken back in Babylon.

CHAPTER 61

This one gets off to a rousing start, as we’re told a bearer of good news has been sent to, “bring good news to the afflicted, to bind up the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, release to the prisoners.”  Yeah, this sounds like news that they’ll be allowed to leave Babylon, but it never clearly says that. 

Also, the line about “bring good news” is a bit St. Paul-esque.  He’ll always go around proclaiming the good news, but in his case it’s Christ. 

It’s a short chapter thanking God for deliverance.  So I suppose the Babylonian Captivity is coming to an end – but it never quite says that.

CHAPTER 62

It’s more good news that I guess refers to the end of the Captivity, but never quite comes out and says so.  It’s about Zion/Jerusalem, and how it’ll now have a new name.  It’ll no longer be “Desolate” or “Forsake” but not “My Delight is in her” and “Espoused.” 

Part of my problem with assuming that this means the captivity is over is that throughout we’ve seen Isaiah refer to the future as if it’s ongoing, so you really can’t tell wishful prophecies with actual reality.

CHAPTER 63

This one gets off to a start that is distinctive and gruesome.  Hark – there is a rider in the distance!  A lone rider coming from Edom!  Who can it be and what has he done?

It’s God.  And he’s just come back from Edom after chewing gum and kicking some ass – and he didn’t bring any bubble gum.  He’s covered in blood from all the people of Edom he slaughtered.  Um……hurrah?  The footnotes say that the Edomites pillaged the Hebrew lands when they were sent to Babylon.  So this is just a revenge fantasy.

The only takes six verses, but the rest of the chapter is more junk DNA. 

CHAPTER 64

Now this one is totally at odds with the theory that the Hebrew are back in their Promised Land.  Here, there is a big plea to God to remember his people and be nice to them again.  We’re told, “Do not be so very angry, Lord, do not remember our crimes forever; look upon us, who are all your people!  Your holy cities have become a wilderness; Zion has become wilderness; Jerusalem desolation!” 

That’s a lot more specific than anything that makes it sound like their back in town.  All the back in town stuff sounds so overblown that it seems unrealistic.  But this sounds like they are still stuck in Babylon.

CHAPTER 65

It’s more of the same.  After 64 chapters, it’s hard for Isaiah to be too original, even if this is the second or third prophet covered in the chapter. 

The entire chapter is from the point of view of God talking.  He promises to treat the good people well, and the bad people poorly.  This is another moment where the Bible ignores everything in Job and acts like the future will be a purely moral wonderland. 

Well, I’ll give it credit for some nice rhetoric, as God says through Isaiah: “My servants shall eat, but you shall go hungry.  My servants shall drink, but you shall be thirsty.  My servants shall rejoice, but you shall be put to shame.  My servants shall shout for joy of heart, but you shall cry out of grief of heart and howl of anguish of spirit.”  The “you” in every case is the people violating his laws.  But you probably figured that out on your own.

Oh, and at the end of the chapter, some of the most famous lines previously given in Isaiah are rehashed: “The wolf and the lamb shall pasture together, and the lion shall eat hay like the ox, but the serpent’s food shall be dust.”  Well, it starts off nice – but then God had to take a swipe at the snake.  I guess God still holds a grudge ever since Eden.  He is sick of these motherfucking snakes on this motherfucking planet.

CHAPTER 66

The longest non-Psalms book in the Bible ends on a rather threatening note.  God warns people, “For see, the Lord will come in fire, his chariots like the stormwind; to wreak his anger in burning rage and his rebuke in fiery flames.  For with fire the Lord shall enter into judgment, and, with his sword, against all flesh, those slain by the Lord shall be many.”   Jeepers, the boss sure is cheesed. 

And it’s weird because the main thrust of the last chapters is positive – going back to Jerusalem and all of the positive things that’ll come.  But you can’t just give people the sunny side.  You need the rod to go with the carrot, and so we’re reminded of the dangers that can come from angering the Lord. 

The book ends with people coming to Jerusalem and we hear from God: “They shall go out and see the corpses of the people who rebelled against me.  For their worm shall not die, their fire shall not be extinguished, and they shall be an abhorrence to all.”  That’s how the book ends, with God warning that those who disobey will just be left to rot in the fields as abhorrence. 

Isaiah has his moments, but he’ll never make it as a Hollywood screenwriter with a curtain closer like that.

CONCLUDING THOUGHTS

Whew!  This is a long sucker.  It has some really strong moments, too.  It has great moments of rhetoric and passion.  This has some memorable visions of the future – a horrible period followed by a purified world for the survivors.  There are plenty of times when the book sets up Christianity, and those are often among the best parts of it.

But there is a ton of Biblical junk DNA.  You get entire chapters of curses for people who no longer exist.  You get Isaiah weighing in on international diplomacy from nearly 3,000 years ago.  Most of all, you get tons of repetition, as the same basic points get made time and time and time and time and time again. 

Overall, it’s a good book, but it’s really hit or miss.  It’s a great 15-20 chapter Biblical book spread out of 66 chapters.




Monday, November 11, 2013

Isaiah: Chapters 48 to 55

Here is the previous bit.



CHAPTER 48

God castigates the Children of Israel for not always following his ways.  But don’t worry, God will remember them eventually. He says at one point, “For the sake of my name I restrain my anger. For the sake of my renown I hold it back from you lest I destroy you.”  Am I the only one who thinks God sounds like a self-important jerk here?  (To be fair, if anyone is going to sound self-important, yeah – it may as well be God).

It gets better later, with another great moment of Isaiah rhetoric: “If only you would attend to my commandments, your peace would be like a river, your vindication like the waves of the sea.  Your descendents like the sand, the offspring of your loins like its grains, their name never cut off or blotted out from my presence.”  I’m not sure what it means exactly “peace like a river” – what dose that mean?  But it sure sounds nice.

Oh, and the chapter ends on a fairly famous line: “There is no peace for the wicked, says the Lord.”  The famous phrase is “no rest for the wicked” but that just sounds like a variation on this line.

CHAPTER 49

In a rather unexpected start, Isaiah II tells us that he was called by the Lord from his mother’s womb to be a prophet.  Really?  I’d heard that about Jeremiah, but not Isaiah.  In fact, earlier in the book we were told he’d received the call around 742 BC.  I guess this is a sign that there is more than one prophet here – the 742 BC guy and this anonymous guy. 

It’s a bunch of fairly standard stuff, except for the end, when he gets really grizzly on what will happen to the enemies of the Hebrew after they’ve returned to Jerusalem: “I will make your oppressors eat their own flesh, and they shall be drunk with their own bloods, as though with new wine.”  Gross. 

CHAPTER 50

We start veering towards Christianity here, as we’re told that the people will achieve salvation through the Lord’s servant.  Isaiah never really makes clear who or what this servant is, but the Christians sure have their answer – Christ (of course).  Frankly, the entire concept of salvation is more in tune with Christianity.  Sure, it comes up here in Isaiah, but otherwise … not so much.  At least not yet. 

God says (through Second Isaiah) of his servant: “I gave my back to those who beat me, my cheeks to those who tore out my beard.  My face I did not hide from insults and spitting.”  That sounds a little like Christ’s passion.

There’s a little bit of Christ foreshadowing here, but an utter ton will come up in a few chapters.

CHAPTER 51

Not much to say about this one.  It repeatedly (OK, twice – but that still counts as repeatedly) calls out, “you who know justice.”  Keep faith in the Lord, but the day of deliverance is coming. 

God notes, “My salvation shall remain forever” which sure sounds a lot like heaven and I’m sure is taken to mean that by Christians, but in the context I don’t think that’s the point. In context, deliverance from Babylon is forever.


CHAPTER 52

It’s another chapter celebrating the imminent return to Zion for the Jews.  “Never again shall the uncircumcised or the unclean enter you,” God says of Jerusalem.  Yeah, well, that won’t work out too well actually.  Jerusalem will be almost always run by non-Jews in the years heading forward.

The end of the chapter starts hitting us heavily with the references to this mysterious servant person that Christians can clearly see as references to Christ.  Isaiah says, “my servant shall prosper, he shall be raised high and greatly exalted.”  Yes, Christ will be exalted, though much of the esteem he gets will come after death.

Going on, Isaiah notes< “Even as man were amazed by him” – yup, he turns water into wine and all that – “so marred were his features” – yup, whipping, crown of thorns, crucifixion – “beyond that of mortals” – yup, not mortal and went through extreme pain –“his appearance, beyond that of human beings – so shall he startle many nations kings shall stand speechless.” 

Yeah, it’s easy to see this as a bunch of foreshadowing for Jesus Christ.  But that’s nothing.  Chapter 53 goes full tilt mode in setting the stage for Christianity.

CHAPTER 53

By my count, the Catholic Bible’s Old Testament contains 1,074 different chapters.  But none of them contains as much direct and blatant foreshadowing of Jesus Christ than this one.  What makes this so striking isn’t just that some ideas are presented that can be used by Christians – like the frequent references in Isaiah to “my servant.”  No, what makes this so notable is how the theology of this fits so well with Christianity.  Hell, if I didn’t know better, I’d wonder if St. Paul actually wrote this and then had it stowed away in Isaiah to justify all the things he’ll say about Jesus Christ later on.

Nearly every single line of this chapter helps pave the way for Christianity.  It starts out a bit vague, saying, “Who would believe what we have heard?”  Eh, that can refer to almost anything.  “To whom the arm of the Lord has been revealed?”  Well, that sounds a bit Christ-like but it can still be taken many different ways.

But Isaiah clearly is thinking of one person, as he says, “He grew up like a sapling before him” and “”He had a majestic bearing to catch our eye.”  So it’s a person, but still – it can be many different people. 

But we’re just getting warmed up people.  Isaiah goes on: “He was spurned and avoided by men, a man of suffering, knowing pain.”  Suffering?  Spurned? Knowing pain?  Why all that sort of stuff is crucial to Christian theology.  And the second half of the verse goes, “Like one from whom you turn your face, spurned and we held him in no esteem.”  Yeah, Christ was spurned in held in no esteem. 

But it really kicks into gear.  So far, it’s just been references and ideas that Christianity can use.  Now Isaiah decides to dump some heavy and obvious Christian theology on us:

“Yet it was our pain that he bore, our sufferings he endured.  We thought of him as stricken, struck down by God and afflicted.  But he was pierced for our sings, crushed for our iniquity.  He bore the punishment that makes us whole, by his wounds we were healed.” 

Whoah!  This is the Old Testament?  Seriously – is there a single word there that wouldn’t fit in beautifully with St. Paul’s theology of Christ’s life and death?  Usually references to a savior or messiah in the Old Testament take on a more earthly form.  The savior will save the people from an earthly plight and re-establish David’s kingdom on earth.  That’s a big part of the reason why it’s important that the savior be from the House of David – the house that the Lord has made a covenant with to rule over his people on earth.  But this chapter?  It’s not a warrior savior at all.  It’s a savior who will take all of our sins upon himself and die for us.  He’ll be the human form of a scapegoat.  This is pure Christian theology.

And it goes on, with Isaiah saying, ‘We had all gone astray like sheep, all following our own way, but the Lord laid upon him, the guilt of us all.  Though harshly treated, he submitted and did not open his mouth. Like a lamb led a slaughter or a sheep silent before shearers, he did not open his mouth.”

Lamb to the slaughter?  That sure is a famous line.  And Lord knows the imagery of Christ with a lamb is an image with staying power. 

And it goes on, “Seized and condemned, he was taken away.  Who would have thought any more of his destiny?  For he was cut off from the land of the living, struck for the sins of his people.  He was given a grave among the wicked, a burial place with evildoers, though he had done no wrong, nor was deceit found in his mouth.”  Again, this is pure Christian theology.  He’ll die for us – and who expects to hear from again after he’s buried.  But even as it’s written here, it’s clear that his destiny is not yet over, even though he’s been killed.

“But it was the Lord’s will to crush him with pain, by making his life as a reparation offering, he shall see his offspring, shall lengthen his days, and the Lord’s will shall be accomplished through him.”  The Lord’s will shall be accomplished through him via his death?  Yup, Christ’s death frees people from original sin.

“Because of his anguish, he shall see light; because of his knowledge he shall be content.  My servant, the just one, shall justify the man, their iniquity he shall bear.”  I doubt many places in the New Testament will  do directly state Christian beliefs as this chapter here, tucked safely away in the Old Testament.  I can only imagine that guys like St. Paul were familiar with this chapter and used it to form early Christian theology to interpret Christ’s death in a way that allowed his teachings to survive his earthly end. 

CHAPTER 54

This is a much more generic chapter.  It just talks about how great things will be in Jerusalem once the Jews finally get back there.  It speaks of Jerusalem as if it’s a barren woman.  But this barren woman will soon have a multitude of kids before her.

CHAPTER 55

I love the opening line of this chapter: “All you who are thirsty, come to the water.”  Sometimes, it’s the basic analogies that work best. 

This chapter is called “An invitation to Grace” and calls on the believers to come before the Lord’s way, as they’re told, “I will make with you an everlasting covenant” – another line that can be used easily by Christians.

Here is another great moment in rhetoric you can imagine your favorite preacher man saying: “Let the wicked forsake their way, and sinners their thoughts.  Let them turn to the Lord to find mercy, to our God, who is generous and forgiving.”  Well, maybe it isn’t as great as some of the other spots I’ve quoted, but it’s nice nonetheless. 

This ends the Second Isaiah section.  The last 11 chapters are supposed to be to Third Isaiah, and written after the Jews have returned to Jerusalem.  (That said, I supposed the Second and Third Isaiahs could be the same guy.  The gap isn’t too big, unlike with First & Second Isaiah). 

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Isaiah: Chapters 40 to 47

Click here for the previous bit of Isaiah.


CHAPTER 40

OK, now comes the Second Isaiah.  Officially, everything in this book goes to one prophet: Isaiah.  But in one of the few moments of essentially universal agreement among Biblical scholars, there is no way that’s so.

The first 39 chapters come from a prophet who we’re told got the call in 742 BC and survived the big siege of Jerusalem 20 years later.  But the guy behind Chapters 40-55 is living in the Babylonian Captivity, which began decades after the siege.  Well, maybe he just lived a long time – except that he’ll name check Cyrus the Great of Persia, who is the man that ended the siege.  Folks. The Captivity last over 70 years and didn’t begin until maybe 40 years after Isaiah got the call, and he was an adult when the got the call and … yeah, that doesn’t add up.

Also, nowhere at all in Chapters 40-55 is Isaiah ever named.  Whoever had these visions never thought to tell us his name.  If you think about it, that makes sense. He’s living in Babylon and foretelling the collapse of Babylon.  Yeah, that might not fly.  So he stays anonymous.  Then later on, it sounds similar to Isaiah of old, and so all gets run together. 

It also explains why Chapters 36-39 are where they are.  They are this weird historical addendum upon the prophecies.  Why put an addendum in the middle of the book?  Because it’s an addendum to the original Isaiah, before you get into the Second Isaiah.

Here, Second Isaiah says that the Lord will save his people.  They’ve done their time, the big man has had his wrath – but it’ll all be good soon.  In the mean time, make sure you don’t fall into the trap of worshipping false idols.  Yeah, God still really hates that. 

CHAPTER 41

God is praised as the liberator of Israel.  This is just what people want to here while living in Babylon.  All before God are unimportant.  All other rulers are nothing: “Ah, all of them are nothing, their works are naught, their idols, empty wind!” 

God even gets in some digs at the Children of Israel as well: “Do not fear, you worm Jacob, you maggot Israel.”  Hey – that’s mean.  It’s a strange way of addressing the people he’s here to save.  Even when God spoke in the whirlwind to chastise Job he didn’t talk like that – and he was doing his damnedest to Big Time Job there.  The God of Second Isaiah, like the God of First Isaiah, can be a wrathful God still.

CHAPTER 42

This is one of those chapters Christians really like.  It foretells a servant of the Lord who will come, a servant who, “shall bring forth justice to the nations.”  It’s not really clear here if the servant is a person or a group or what, but if you’re into the New Testament, an obvious answer is Jesus Christ.  Then again, if you’re a Jew, it isn’t necessarily Christ. 

In the second half of the chapter, God promises to look after Israel and restore them.

CHAPTER 43

God keeps talking about Israel, and what his promises for them are.  Frankly, this is a side of God I don’t much care for.  Aside from being vengenceful and occasionally genocidal, the God of the Old Testament tends to be rather parochial, and that’s what he is here.  He tells the Hebrew through Second Isaiah that: “I give Egypt as ransom for you, Ethiopia and Seba in exchange for you.  Because you are precious in my eyes and honored and I love you.”  Yeah, screw all of them other peoples out there.

This narrowness of God’s visions works in the context of the ancient Near East, where all civilizations and tribes and cities think they have their own protector God.  But those groups see their God as one among many God.  Now the Hebrew have decided that their God is the only God.  He’s the all-mighty God.  He is the creator of all God.  He is the God that all people should fear and obey.  But he’s still just their God.  There is something there that just doesn’t add up.  Christianity will come around later to resolve that dilemma, but here God still has a Chosen People, a concept I have no use for.

CHAPTER 44

God keeps going on.  Since we get no info on the prophet Second Isaiah, all of this section of the Bible is just God talking through the prophet/vessel. 

Mostly, false gods are denounced.  God takes an approach made previously in the Bible, but never as effectively as here.  A man cuts down a tree, puts half of the wood in the fire and carves the other half of the wood into a god, then worships that carving.  Doesn’t that sound silly to anyone else?  Well it sure sounds silly when you put it that way.  Similar points are made throughout the Bible – heck, it’s made in Chapter 40.  But Chapter 44 really nails it, I think.

Oh, and at the end the chapter takes a new direction: the prophet name-drops Cyrus of Persia.  Yeah, that’s a good sign that this has to be a different prophet.  People just don’t live that long.

CHAPTER 45

Cyrus will be God’s instrument of justice.  And that let’s God gave some nifty rhetoric on justice: “Let justice descent, you heavens, like dew from above, like gentle rains let the clouds drop it down.  Let the earth open and salvation bud forth; let righteousness spring up with them!”  Yeah, any preacher worth a damn must spend quality time with the rhetoric of Isaiah.

Actually, this chapter goes a few different directions.  After noting the justice to come, God flips it around by noting how he’ll put people in their place as well.  Some might think they have the right to question him, but God squashes that, saying: “Woe to anyone who asks a father, `What are you begetting?”  or a woman, `What are you giving birth to?’  Thus says the Lord, the Holy One of Israel, his maker: Do you question me about my children, tell me how to treat the work of my hands?  It was I who made the earth and created the people upon it.  It was my hands that stretched out the heavens.”  He’s God so he gets to determine things.  It’s comes with the territory.  Yeah, that makes sense.

But then he goes back to being a parochial God, who might rule over all but really only cares about the Hebrew.  He tells them, “The earnings of Egypt, the gain of Ethiopia, and the Sabeans, tall of stature, shall come over to you and belong to you.  They shall follow you, coming in chains.”  Sigh. Oh, and you were doing so well, chapter.  You were doing so well until there.

CHAPTER 46

This short – 13-verse chapter – is about the gods of Babylon.  Short version: screw them, they ain’t real. There is God and that’s it.

CHAPTER 47

Now that we’ve dismissed Babylon’s gods, let’s talk about Babylon’s fall.  It relates to their gods, of course.  Babylon was only successful because God wanted to use them as an instrument to punish his people with.  Well, they did that and take all the credit for themselves and their phony gods.  So screw them. 

One line I found interesting – God says to the Babylonians: “Your wisdom and your knowledge led you astray.”  That fits with the story of Solomon – very wise, but not very faithful – but sounds rather strange right after all those Wisdom Books.  In Proverbs and Wisdom and Ben Sira and others we heard wisdom praised to the heights.  It was the best thing this side of God, or as great as God.  It’s God’s best gift to us.

But there, wisdom was a way to understand God and his world.  Here?  Wisdom is just a way to gain knowledge, not necessarily about God.  And the Babylonians have used it like that.  Whereas most of the Bible seems to embrace learning, this is a throwaway line that can used for those who opposed secular humanism.    

Click here for the next bunch of Isaiah.