Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Book of Lamentations

Click here for the end of Jeremiah.



CHAPTER 1

This is a poem mourning the loss of Jerusalem.  Get used to it – that’s what the entire chapter is. 

At first it describes Jerusalem as a widow, with no one left to mourn for her.  That said, the characterizations seemed more like a whore.  That’s too harsh and nasty, but there is an undercurrent of criticism that isn’t always such an undercurrent.  Ultimately, the poet responsible for this believes that this is God’s just punishment for the sinful ways of the people of Jerusalem. 

Early on, the authors writes of the abandoned city, ‘She has no one to comfort her from all her lovers.”  Calling Jerusalem a she and then noting many lovers – that doesn’t sound like a positive connotation in the Bible.  Later on, the poem shifts to first person and Jerusalem itself cries out, “I cried out to my lovers, but they failed me.”

Maybe I’m thinking this in too sexual of terms.  I keep going back and forth with this.  At times I think I’m making too much of it, but then I look at it, and again – since when is it a good thing in the Bible for any sort of female to have multiple lovers?  However, I look at the poem in that direction – that it’s criticizing Jerusalem for unfaithfulness – and I see something else.

There is a lot of serious mourning here.  The poet flatly breaks down in tears later on.  He is horrified how desolate the city is.  No, it’s not a poem primarily criticizing the city.  It’s one primarily mourning it. But the mourning is tinged with this sense of deserving it.

Also, the line, “Her uncleaniness is on her skirt” made me thing of Monica Lewinksy.  I doubt that’s what it means, but that’s where my mind went.

I’m not very happy with my analysis of this chapter, but that’s life sometimes.

CHAPTER 2

Lamentations is a collection of five poems around the same theme – the loss of Jerusalem, with each chapter being a different poem. 

This one starts off by noting God’s anger.  It sounds positively Jeremiah-ian when it declares, “The Lord has become the enemy, he has devoured Israel.”  Well, Jeremiah would probably say Israel has become the enemy, but the result is the poet thinks that God is personally against his supposed people. 

Our poet takes this especially hard, so much so that he ends up vomiting.  Really.  He writes, “My eyes are spent with tears, my stomach churns.  My bile is poured out on the ground at the brokenness of the daughter of my people.”  Stomach churning then bile pouring?  Yep, sounds like someone just puked. I do believe that’s the first puke in the entire Bible.

He sounds desolate, and mirrors what is said in the Book of Deuteronomy, as he writes, “Must women eat their own offspring.”  When I first read those lines of cursing in Deuteronomy, I figured it was some hyperbole; poetic license.  But we’re hearing the same things here.  Maybe these Lamentations were written long after the fact and were cribbing from Deuteronomy.  But then again …Jerusalem was under siege.  Surely some did resort to cannibalism when the food ran out. Yeah, maybe some mothers really did eat their own newborn.  Yikes.  Maybe not, but I’m starting to wonder.

CHAPTER 3

This is easily the longest poem in Lamentations.  At 66 verses, it’s exactly three times longer than any of the other chapters.  Incredibly, it’s exactly three times the length  of all the other chapters. Yes, that’s right, every other chapter in the book is exactly 22 verses long.  Neat.

This one starts off with utter despair.  I know Lamentations is all about despair, but nothing and I mean nothing out-despairs the early parts of Chapter 3.  Our poet tells us that, “Even when I cry for help, [God] stops my prayer.”  Wow.  That’s a novel concept - -God using his all mighty power to prevent people from praying.  That’s a new one.

Later on, he tells us: “I have forgotten what happiness is.  My enduing hope, I said, has perished before the Lord.”  Normally people turn to the Bible to find hope, yet hear we see a section of the Bible itself without hope.

But the mood doesn’t last.  About a third the way through, he makes a turn, noting: “But this I will call to mind; therefore I will hope.”  OK, good.  I was beginning to wonder about this guy.  I’m glad to hear he’s found reason for hope.  Sure life sucks, but he finds his rock to hold onto: “For the Lord does not reject forever.”  You know, speaking as a non-religious Bible reading, I find that to be an especially wonderful statement.  It’s one of my favorite lines in the Bible so far.  And it makes sense.  If you were all powerful and all mighty and all that – would you really want to waste your time on grudges?  What’s the point of being omnipotent if you’re going to waste it on eternal pettiness?

He goes on, and looks forward to the day when God will come back to the Children of Israel.  It looks like it’s going to end on an uplifting note, and I’m sure the poet things it does – but it’s the worst kind of uplifting note.  You know what’ll really prove God is back on the side of the Hebrew?  If he kills their enemies.  Yes, this lovely poem ends screaming for vengeance.

This is like the long lost 151st psalm.  It contains many elements of psalms; both the best and worst of them.

CHAPTER 4

This one puts the focus back on Jerusalem.  It’s called, “Miseries of the Besieged City.”  Once again, we’re told that women have eaten their own newborn: “The hands of compassionate women have boiled their own children!”  Again – did this really happen?  Maybe.  It just might have happened. 

It features some good lines, too.  “Even jackals offer their breasts to nurse their young.”  That’s a nice analogy for a people who feel totally adrift.  Later we’re told, “Better for those pierced by the sword than for those pierced by hunger.”  Plenty of parts in the Bible (or many other places) feel that the dead have it better than the living, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen the sentiment so succinctly put as here. 

Much like Chapter 3, this one ends on a note of revenge.  This time, there’s a specific target: Edom.  Apparently, Edom is gloating at the destruction of their bossy neighbor.  Laugh it up, Edom boy. You’ll get yours. 

CHAPTER 5

This is just another plea to the Lord to be remembered.  Unlike the other poems, which all sound like they take place in the immediate aftermath of Jerusalem’s fall, this one sounds like it’s from later.  The poet writes, “Our ancestors, who sinned, are no more; but now we bear their guilt.” 

I guess that’s why it’s at the end of the book.  It’s more a longing to return that a horrific memory of what was lost.

CONCLUDING THOUGHTS

It’s a decent enough chapter and the poems read fairly well.  It’s certainly not the most ambitious book in the Bible, but it hits its mark for the most part.

Click here for the next book, Baruch. 

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Jeremiah: Chapters 46 to 52

Click here for the previous part of Jeremiah.


CHAPTER 46

Now we get into the final parts of Jeremiah, which frankly aren’t that interesting.  They are mostly a series of curses against foreign nations.  This one is against Egypt.

It doesn’t seem like the same prophet.  I suppose it could be, but its weird reading Jeremiah show any sort of nationalistic overtones.  Well, he was never anti-Judah, just all pro-God, and if God didn’t like foreign nations either, then Jeremiah would express that.

Except I don’t really buy that.  The problem here isn’t just the subject matter, but the tone and focus.  There is a phrase I like to apply to many things in life: you can’t see the forest through the trees.  Sometimes you focus so much on the immediate and narrow view you can miss the broader picture.  Jeremiah, for all his memorable passion, is perhaps the Bible’s most tree-centric prophet.  He starts off with the big scale prophecies, but when they don’t go over well, he spends much of the rest of his time fending off enemies, feuding with his enemies, issuing curses towards his enemies, and trying not to be killed by his enemies.  When would he have time/interest for this stuff?

Also, if Jeremiah was issuing curses against all other peoples, wouldn’t that have mitigated his unpopularity in Judah? I guess he could be doing this from Egypt.  That would explain why he’s denouncing Egypt.  But he’s about to denounce everyone else in the next few chapters, and lands far away have never been Jeremiah’s focus.  (Also, there is nothing to really indicate that this part is put in chronologically in his life story).

One last thing – he is way too nice to the Hebrews.  Instead of comparing them to lusty camels or describing how and why God wants them to lose Jerusalem, he’s saying, “But you, my servant Jacob, do not fear; do not be dismayed, Israel!”  and “You, Jacob, my servant, must not fear – oracle of the Lord – for I am with you.”  Yeah, Jeremiah had some positive things to say on occasion towards his countrymen, but this time his attitude to them seems to be entirely generic.  This is nothing distinctly Jeremiah in how he views his fellow Hebrew.

CHAPTER 47

This is a short chapter in which he denounces Philistines. 

CHAPTER 48

This is a long chapter in which Jeremiah denounces Moab.  Again, after those first 45 chapters, it’s just weirdly jarring to see Jeremiah suddenly sound like some sort of Hebrew nationalist.  You can square the circle and say it still works.  Those other guys don’t believe in God either.  Yeah, but in Isaiah it’s pretty clear there are 2-3 different prophets at work.  (Either that or Isaiah lived 200 years or so).  So we already know that these books on prophecies can combine different guys.  It just strikes me as some other prophet having his words put in Jeremiah’s mouth.

CHAPTER 49

It’s a grab bag of curses: Ammonites, Edom, Damascus, Arabia, and Elam all get their turn to be curses by “Jeremiah.”  This can get awkward if you follow much of current Middle East foreign policy.  Inside Israel there is an increasingly strong right wing movement that takes inspiration and comfort from parts of the Bible that ensures the Jews that Israel is theirs.  Well, here all their neighbors are being cursed and denigrated.

CHAPTER 50

This is the first of two long chapters (110 verses in total) that curse Babylon.  Please remember that Jeremiah’s main claim to fame (or infamy in the eyes of his fellow countrymen) was that he said God wanted Babylon to take over Judah.  That was the main reason why so many wanted so badly to kill Jeremiah – he was saying this even during war when Jerusalem was under siege and running out of bread. 

Now he’s saying, “Call archers out against Babylon, all who bend the bow, encamp around them; let no one escape.  Repay them for their deeds.”  Repay them for their deeds?  You mean the deeds you earlier said God approved of them doing?

Well, not quite, as “Jeremiah” says, “For they insulted the Lord.”  Oh, OK – but how?  We don’t get much info.  If this really was Jeremiah doing a complete about face, you’d think he’d explain himself better than this.  Remember: Jeremiah earlier referred to the Babylonian king as his servant.  Not just his tool or instrument – but this servant – because he was going to destroy the kingdom of Judah.  Now the Babylonians are evil, and we need some more on why you suddenly think that, pal.

CHAPTER 51

It’s more curses against Babylon.  It’s 64 verses of redundant blah-blah-blah.  This supposed-Jeremiah at least knows the language of the original guy, as he says “What a horror Babylon has become among nations!”  Yeah, that’s just what the old guy said about Judah. 

Oh, the end of this section explains what this part is doing in the Bible.  We’re told that Jeremiah wrote down these words and had them sent to Babylon, to be read aloud.  So my hunch is that someone forged it in the name of Jeremiah and had it sent to Babylon to be passed off in his name.  Jeremiah can’t stop it.  He’s over in Egypt (assuming he’s still alive when this was written). 

Think for a second: if it were a forgery – how would Jeremiah even know about it, let alone stop it?  For that matter, how could the Jews in Babylon determine it’s authenticity?  They’d think it’s real maybe because they’d want to.  Some language is the same, and Jeremiah always was good at complaining – so sure, let’s say it’s really him.  Oh, as an added bonus, there is a big of theater to go with it.  The scroll reader is told to tie a stone to the scroll and throw it in the river, telling everyone that Babylon will sink like that stone.  Jeremiah was always good at some street theater, but that doesn’t mean it’s him.

The focus and aim of this is just too off-kilter.  It could be Jeremiah.  We have no way of knowing one way or the other.  But that’s just it – we have no way of knowing, but they assumed it was and put it in the Bible anyway.

CHAPTER 52

This is just a narrative chapter about the fall of Jerusalem.  We already read this about 10 chapters or so ago.  Plus we read it in Kings II, as well.  But we get it again.  My Bible’s footnotes say it’s inserted here to show the fulfillment of Jeremiah’s prophecy.  OK – but that already happened about 10 chapters ago. 

CONCLUDING THOUGHTS


This is a remarkable book.  You get a much clearer since of the individual prophet than you do in Isaiah.  You get a much clearer sense of his personality.  It isn’t always a very pretty personality.  He is petty.  He does a terrible job trying to relate to the people. In fact, I’m not sure he even cares to.  God tells him that the Hebrew are doomed and he tells everyone that.  He never tries to intercede with God like Abraham or Moses or some others.  His prophecies and demeanor end up alienating everyone.  You have to wonder what his point as a prophet was if he was just going to have so little impact on his people.

Well, his purpose as prophet wasn’t for the people then, but for those you came later.  Here’s a thought I noted earlier: without Jeremiah, does the religion survive the Captivity?  Jeremiah is able to construct the narrative that the Jews will use to explain why – if their God is so all-powerful – they lost their land, their capital, their temple, and even the ark of the Lord itself.  It would be hard to build that narrative on the fly after the fact, and if you don’t have that narrative figured out, that Judah will go the way of the 10 lost tribes of the North, and melt into the rest of the communities.  So that is Jeremiah’s purpose as a prophet.

And while he can be petty and is utterly ineffectual in his own life, he is still at times admirable.  He never does back down, no matter how low his prospects get.   His own personal trauma and internal turmoil makes him pitiable – but only to some extent.  Given that he doesn’t seem to feel much pity for anyone else, it’s hard to have much for him.

But this all misses the point.  What makes this book stick out for me isn’t trying to moralize about Jeremiah as a good or bad person or an effective or not prophet.  The most striking sense I get from him is what a compelling character he is.  He leaps off the page as a distinctive person with his own distinctive voice.  That makes this such a memorable Bible book.  

Click here for Lamentations.

Monday, November 18, 2013

Jeremiah: Chapters 36 to 45

Click here for the previous part.



CHAPTER 36

We get some weird alternating back-and-forth here. Every other chapter lately has been part of the main narrative.  Chapter 32 had a siege in Jerusalem, 34 had the siege still going on, and now back in Chapter 36 we’re back at it. 

The star of this chapter is Jeremiah’s scribe Baruch.  Well, star is probably too strong, but he is a key player.  His main duty is to transcribe Jeremiah’s writings.  OK, that means Jeremiah is likely illiterate.  That isn’t too surprising given the era – but actually it is a little surprising. This man is the son of a priest, after all.  But he has Baruch write down all his prophecies instead of doing it himself.

He wants Baruch to write them down and read them by the temple.  You see, Jeremiah can’t do it himself.  He’s been banned from the temple.  That isn’t terribly surprising if you’ve been following along so far.  Baruch does it, reading them from a place near the temple (within shouting distance, quite literally).  The place belongs to a man named Gemariah, whose father Shaphan had been the secretary of state under Josiah.  There is the old Josiah connection again.  He was the reformer king when Deuteronomy was “uncovered” (re: written) and Jeremiah is a big proponent of the laws of Dueteronomy. 

Baruch is asked about his scroll, and acknowledges that he transcribed it all from Jeremiah.  Once he says that, people advice him to go into hiding, and he does so (as does Jeremiah).  The scroll of Jeremiah’s prophecies – essentially, the first draft of this book I’m reading – is given to the king.  He has it all read to him.  Every so often, the king cuts a piece off of it and throws it in the fire.  No, he isn’t a fan.  That isn’t too surprising.  After all, he’s on the verge of having his kingdom destroyed by Babylon, and here is Jeremiah saying that God wills Babylon to take Jerusalem to punish the Jews.

The king is so offended he orders Jeremiah and Baruch arrested.  But it’s too late – they’ve gone into hiding. While in hiding, they hear their scroll has been destroyed.  Well then, that means they’ll have to write it all over again.  And so they do.

I’ll say this much for Jeremiah.  While he clearly isn’t the most pleasant of all prophets, he certainly has the courage of his convictions.  Sure, Moses had to deal with problems, too, but back then God would always help out with miracles.  Jeremiah is out there on his own, facing down his critics with nothing more than his own convictions.  But he keeps rising up, despite his own internal qualms about it.


CHAPTER 37


With Jerusalem struggling to hold out, Jeremiah continues to issue his depressing prophecies.  He’s asked by the powers that be to ask God for help.  They don’t get the answer they like.  Jeremiah let’s them know that the news from God hasn’t changed – they are doomed and may as well give up.  They didn’t like being insulted by Jeremiah when things were going well, but this is too much. 

Jeremiah goes to his native territory of Benjamin to do some business dealings about land (it’s a call back to the land stuff mentioned in Chapter 32).  However, he’s picked up by authorities who find the whole thing rather suspicious – and they have a point.  Here is Jeremiah, the man who consuls them to surrender to the enemy – trying to skate out of town.  Oh, you say you’re doing business dealings in the land of Benjamin!  BAH!  They don’t believe them.  They thing he’s defecting.  It’s a reasonable guess, given how little loyalty Jeremiah has shown to the state. (I don’t really doubt Jeremiah, as he consistently is willing to say things that put himself in harm’s way).

Please note, the people putting him under arrest are the princes – the same guys who saved him from being lynched in Chapter 26.  They were willing to defend him when his prophecies were just a matter of theology, but now Jerusalem itself is imperiled.  They throw him in the dungeon.  When he’s taken out, he repeats his previous statements – Babylon will win because God wants them to. 

Jeremiah then says the most naïve thing in the book, perhaps in the Bible.  He tells the king: “How have I wronged you or your officials, or this people that you should put me in prison?”   Seriously, Jeremiah?  You don’t get it?  The nation is about to collapse and you’re saying “Good!  We deserve it!”  C’mon!  Still, on points Jeremiah is right – he is an established prophet and precedent says that prophets should be given some leeway.  He is taken out of the prison and held in court.  Essentially, he’s under house arrest.  Really, he’s been treated a lot nicer than I would’ve expected. 

CHAPTER 38

Jeremiah’s treatment worsens as the war goes worse.  This chapter is as close as Jeremiah comes to death; and this is a prophet with more than his share of close shaves. 

The prophet sticks to his approach, and even tells people at the court that everyone will die except those who willingly surrender to the outside army.  Man, that’s borderline treason.  It’s loyal to God, but not to the state.  Actually, this highlights something interesting about the modern world.  The most religious people are often the biggest backers of the regime.  Not always, but by and large you find a strong streak of churchmen backing up established order.  Here in America, the religious are often the most self-consciously patriotic.  Jeremiah is an oddity: he’s fully loyal to God, but shows essentially no loyalty to his land.

The princes – again, the people who saved his ass in Chapter 26 – are the ones most irate at him.  They tell the king that Jeremiah is weakening the resolve of the people.  It’s impossible to argue against that.  Jeremiah is doing just that.

The king has no interest in defending the troublesome prophet.  He puts Jeremiah in their hands and they throw him in a cistern in the royal palace.  (checks dictionary).  Ah, they put him in a tank to store water.  Except this tank has no water in it.  It has just mud and Jeremiah sinks into the mud.  In a bleak book, this is a new low.

Fortunately for him, some guys still take seriously the notion that he’s a prophet of God.  They must be other survivors supporters of the Josiah-era reforms.  The main guy is Ebed-melech, an Ethiopian, and he intercedes with the king to get Jeremiah taken out of the cistern before he dies. 

So Jeremiah survives, and shortly afterwards the king asks Jeremiah for some help.  Wait a second, says Jeremiah, how do I know you won’t have me killed if you tell me what the Lord is thinking?  The guy swears he won’t be put to death.  Jeremiah then gives the king the same bad news as before: Jeremiah is doomed and the only way to save himself is to surrender.

The king keeps his word and even comes up with a cover story.  If anyone asks, Jeremiah is to say that he asked to be not sent back to his earlier prison sentence.  The princes ask, and Jeremiah gives the stock answer.  What is interesting here is that the king’s resolve is clearly crumbling.  We’re also told that they’re running out of break for everyone, so it is nearing the end. 

I wonder what the source for the two paragraphs is.  We’ll soon see that the king isn’t going to last much longer (spoiler!) so either Jeremiah told the story (possible) or it was invented and later inserted (also possible).  It makes it look like even the King will still look to Jeremiah and his moral authority.  Then again, it is believable that as things get desperate the king would turn to anyone for advice, even the gloomiest guy that ever spoke with God.

CHAPTER 39

Jerusalem falls.  So it falls before the leaders can kill Jeremiah.  The leaders make a break for it.  The king is captured, and forced to watch as his sons are killed in front of him.  Then his yes are gouged out and he’s brought back in chains to Babylon.  He does survive, but that’s a hell of way to survive.  The princes also make a break for it, and are killed.

Jeremiah is released from custody put under the care of Gedaliah, who is given control of the land by the Babylonians.  Jeremiah gives one of his rare good sermons, praising Ebed-melech, the Ethiopian who saved Jeremiah from the cistern. 

CHAPTER 40

This is just a chapter of plot points.  Babylon still has the land, and Gedaliah is their appointed governor.  Jeremiah consuls the people to serve their new overlords, but naturally not everyone is on board.  The chapter ends with the readers learning that a man named Ishmael is taking steps to kill Gedaliah.

CHAPTER 41

And so Ishmael kills Gedaliah.  This is bad news.  The Hebrew just lost a war to Babylon, and now they kill the Babylonian-appointed governor.  Do Ishmael and friends have a plan on what to do next? 

Nope.  They really don’t.  They hightail it out of the old Promised Land and escape back to Egypt.  This is the punishment Moses warned about at the end of Deuteronomy.  If they can’t fulfill God’s laws, he’ll send them back to Egypt where they’ll beg to be enslaved, but no one will buy.  It’s impressive how the old prophecy of Moses is being so eerily fulfilled.  Well, that’s one way of looking at it.  The common way for Biblical scholar belief is that Deuteronomy was first written during the reign of Isaiah and then later modified.  The modifications came around here.  These are all evidence on behalf of Jeremiah being the author of Deuteronomy.  He’s the right man in the right place at the right time with the right message.  If it wasn’t him, it was one of the very few people that stood by him for all of these disastrous years.

(Well, technically speaking it would be Baruch, Jeremiah’s scribe that wrote it, but it’s largely the same thing).

CHAPTER 42

This is a strange chapter.  On the face of it, there is nothing strange about it.  This is just a continuation of the narrative of the last several chapters.  But the motivations and actions of the characters are so odd. 

It reads a little like a later addition to the chapter, in part because it goes back in time a bit.  Last chapter ended with everyone running away to Egypt.  But here, that hasn’t happened yet.  Instead, Ishmael and friends ask Jeremiah for some advice.  Would you kindly ask God for some help?  Pray for us and tell us what to do, and we promise we’ll do whatever he says.

So Jeremiah praises for them to God and waits for the All-Mighty’s response.  In a stunner, the news comes back positive.  God repents his treatment of the Hebrew (!!) and says that if Ishmael and friends decide to stick around, God will look after them.  Wow – just the prophecy the Hebrew have long been looking for from Jeremiah!  Boy, they will be really motivated to defend their lands now, right?

Nope.  They immediately tell Jeremiah to forget that.  We’re getting out of here. 

Wait – what?  Huh?  What the hell is going on?  As near as I can tell, they asked Jeremiah to talk to God, hoping/expecting that he’ll report back more gloomy tidings.  Then Ishmael can run away with divine sanctification.  He’s bitten off more than he can chew, has only belatedly realized that and is looking for Jeremiah to provide him an escape hatch.  Only he doesn’t get it, so he’ll run away.  That’s one theory.

The other theory is that this chapter is a later addition.  Both are reasonable theories, but my hunch is that it’s the latter.  I say that because if this were part of the original story, it would flow better.  Like I said, this story with its odd motivations comes after the previous chapter ended with everyone running away to Egypt. 

Why add in this story later on?  Look at how it makes everyone look.  The Hebrew that fled are now even worse than they were before.  Even when God takes pity on them, they still blow him off.  And it just adds to the overall rejected trajectory of Jeremiah. 

Oh, and God sure is cheesed.  Jeremiah reports to them that for ignoring God yet again, the Lord is now doubly decided to lay into them.  “You shall become a malediction and “a horror, a curse and a reproach, and you shall never see this place again.”  Guys, go fuck yourself.  Sincerely, God.

CHAPTER 43

This just continues Chapter 42.  When Jeremiah finishes laying into them, they respond like you’d expect: “You lie.”  They accuse Jeremiah of setting them up to be slaughtered.  And again, based on Jeremiah’s track record, I don’t totally fault them for wondering that. After all, he’s long said that God will have his revenge on them, and may God is double dealing them to make it happened.  I don’t totally fault them for doubting Jeremiah, but they are wrong to do so.  Jeremiah may not be loyal to Judah, but he’ll always report his prophecies honestly, no matter what the personal cost.  If his story has shown anything, it’s shown that.

They all go to Egypt, and Jeremiah goes with.  God tells him to put up some stones by the Pharaoh’s Temple, saying that the Babylonians will build a throne to themselves there. 

CHAPTER 44

We’re nearly the end of the Jeremiah stories.  Chapter 45 is just a brief blurb, and the last seven chapters are essentially an appendix of various prophecies about various nations.  This is by and large our last big one on Jeremiah and the Hebrew.

They’re all in Egypt now.  I guess it would be at least a moral victory for Jeremiah if the Hebrew were at least chastised by their loss of land.  You’d think that might be the case.  After all, those taken to Babylon will feel that way, redouble their efforts at being loyal to God and come away with their religious convictions strengthened.

Well, that maybe what’s going on in Babylon, but it’s a very different story for Jeremiah in Egypt.  They are sacrificing to other gods, and openly flouting Jeremiah.  Their rationale for doing so is rather interesting, too.  They note how in the good old days, they’d sacrifice to the Goddess of Heaven.  But then they were told to switch it up and sacrifice to God – and look what good it did them?  So the Goddess of Heaven it is.

Jeremiah urges them to hear the word of the Lord, but he’s always really sucked at that.  He hasn’t gotten a single person to move closer to God.  By those standards, he’s a miserable failure of a prophet.  So he just curses them.  They want God to go fuck himself?  Then they can go fuck themselves.  It’s interesting: here Jeremiah is cursing them out.  And they respond in the most crippling way of all: they do try to lynch him, they do throw him in any cistern.  They are just indifferent.  Want to talk about God, Jeremiah?  Go for it.  No ones cares.

Why is this crowd so very different than the faithful in Babylon?  I have one main theory.  The ones going off to Babylon are the leaders, whereas these are mostly poor peasants.  The Babylon crowd have a lot more invested in the official religions because they are the ones in charge of it (and the literate ones who can actually read it).  This Goddess of Heaven jazz is a folk religion.  It’s not sanctioned by scripture, but just believed by commoners in their day-to-day life.  They didn’t have to start praying to the official God until near the end when thinks were going bad.  Since things kept going bad when they switched to him, they consider him to be a failed God.  So they’re back with their Goddess of Heaven.

Here’s another theory on why the Egypt crowd drifts away: the guy pushing them toward God is Jeremiah.  While he is devout and courageous, he’s alienated virtually every single person he’s ever met, save a few like his trusty scribe, Baruch.  In that respect it’s probably for the best for the Babylonian crowd that Jeremiah isn’t around them.

It’s probably a combination of reasons why the exiles in Egypt fall away while those in Babylon stay true; but probably more of the former than the latter.

CHAPTER 45

This is just five verses long.  It’s just Jeremiah having Baruch put words on a scroll.  Most notably, we get a final prophecy from God to Jeremiah: “What I have built, I have tearing down; what I have planted, I am uprooting: all this land.  And you, do you seek great things for yourself?  Do not seek them!  I am bringing evil on all flesh – oracle of the Lord – but I will grant you your life as spoils of war, wherever you may go.” 

That’s a fittingly downbeat endnote.  Don’t seek great things for yourself!  God will let Jeremiah live, but that’s about it.

Oh, there are seven more chapters, but they are disembodied from the main narrative.  Essentially, we’re leaving our boy Jeremiah on a note that amounts to: well, the good news is God will let you live.  But that’s about it.

Click here for the final chapters in Jeremiah.

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Jeremiah: Chapters 29 to 35

Click here for the previous chunk of Jeremiah.


CHAPTER 29

Jeremiah writes a letter to the exiles in Babylon.  At least it’s supposedly by Jeremiah.  Again, he specifically notes they’ll be away for 70 years.  At the very least, that strikes me as an inclusion by a future author, and maybe the entire thing is a forgery. 

It is all pretty standard.  They should be fruitful and multiply in Babylon because they’re the future of the Hebrew.  God wants the Hebrew destroyed for their sins. Jeremiah quotes God saying, “I am handling them over to Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon, who will kill them before your eyes.”  Yikes.

Mind you, Jeremiah has no problem with these sorts of statements.  He doesn’t really have any strong loyalty to his people.  His loyalty is solely to God.  That’s a big part of the reason why people hate him so much.   Can you imagine if some big preacher went around screaming at people that God hates America and wants us all destroyed because of our sinful ways?

Hey wait – we have people like that: Westboro Church.  My God – Jeremiah is the ancient Hebrew version of the Westboro lunatics!

We’re supposed to be on Jeremiah’s side, but that’s tough.  He dwells too much on how people will be punished, and has too many petty disputes with his enemies.  He really isn’t interested in improving people, just in making them pay.  From some angles he is sympathetic because he genuinely believes God is compelling him to say these things, and he doesn’t like how it’s affected his life – but it’s God, dammit. 

Really, with Jeremiah it isn’t about likable or not; if you root for him or don’t.  He’s just plain compelling. 

CHAPTER 30

The next few chapters have a different feel.  They talk about the things no one associates with Jeremiah: hope and redemption.  Jeremiah tells people that God will save them eventually.  They’ll be punished, but after enough time God will come back to them and their land will be restored.

It’s a lot less personal than Jeremiah’s normal prophecies.  Part of me wonders if it’s a later addition/forgery or another prophet wandering in here, but I don’t want to be too skeptical.  Even Jeremiah is allowed to have some optimistic moments.  The fact that it sounds less personal might even work.  He’s good at dealing with the negative, but is a bit less familiar with the positive news.  Saying that God will return to them isn’t the same thing as giving us a precise duration (70 years) like a few chapters do).

CHAPTER 31

More good news.  They’ll return to Jerusalem and all will be happy.  God will be with them again. 

CHAPTER 32

We’re really approaching zero hour here.  Jerusalem is under siege by the Babylonians.  The king of Judah has Jeremiah confined to the court, because the last thing he needs is the damn prophet running around ruining everyone’s morale. 

Jeremiah stands to his position: God wants Babylon to take over and destroy Jerusalem.  It’s interesting because we often think of being religious and being patriotic as good things, and they typically go together.  That had certainly been the case for the Hebrew, who believe that God gave them the land for them because they were His people.  But this link of patriotism and religion doesn’t work for Jeremiah.  For him, it’s God and nothing else. 

There is a weird section here where Jeremiah is told by God to buy some land.  It’s notable because it’s the first mention of Jeremiah’s assistant, Baruch.  Later, Baruch gets his own book in the Bible.  It’s not in the Protestant or Jewish Bibles, but it is in the Catholic Bible.

CHAPTER 33

Jerusalem will be restored.  It’s another happy chapter.  There isn’t much to say about it, that I didn’t say in the previous happy chapters.  They really do feel a little out of place with the overall downbeat vibe of Jeremiah.  One really feels out of place here, where we just had Jerusalem under siege. 

CHAPTER 34

Back to the main narrative.  Now the Babylonian army is attacking Jerusalem itself.  That doesn’t change Jeremiah in the slightest.  There is none of this happy talk of the future where God will restore everything to the Hebrew.  Those chapters are always off on their own little island, detached from the rest of the action.  (That’s one reason I wonder if they were really written by Jeremiah.  At the very least, if he really did have these occasional positive moments, it would’ve made it easier for people to get along with him).

Instead, he issues more curses.  It’s the same stuff we’ve heard before.  Hand you over to your enemies.  Corpses food for birds and beasts.  Cities into a waste.  Rinse, lather, repeat.

CHAPTER 35

This is a weird little offshoot chapter.  It’s about a group called the Rechabites. They are sons I guess and they are faithful, so Jeremiah says don’t worry – God will let your family survive forever.  

Click here for the climax of the Jeremiah stories.